Are the Cubs a “fair weather” offense?

Published on

in

Vintage baseball surrounded by swirling lines and statistical charts

Based on stats in 2026, it appears that they are, performing much better offensively when temperatures are higher. Conversely, their pitchers are much better when the temperatures drop.

My hypothesis would be that this correlates very closely with wind direction, as the wind typically blows out during warm days at Wrigley field. But we will take a look at what the numbers reflect.

Fangraphs splits tool has a very cool feature that allows you to track individual and team performance based on weather. This feature goes at-bat by at-bat, so withing the same game, the temperature or wind might change, which would be reflected in the stats.

Let’s start with a simple chart of splits when temps are below or above 75 degrees:

TemperaturePAsRunsR/PAOPSwRC+
74 and below29013410.118.714102
75 and above31074650.150.820127

Let’s split that up by home versus road

TemperaturePAsRunsR/PAOPSwRC+
74 and below home16801810.108.706102
74 and below road12211600.131.725102
75 and above home13742340.170.903151
75 and above road15342310.151.755108

So, it is obvious that weather plays more of a factor at home than on the road. S that makes me even more sure that the wind is playing a big part. Now sometimes the wind is neutral, but lets look first at win blowing in versus out for these same numbers:

Wind at WrigleyPAsRunsR/PAOPSwRC+
Blowing In9131050.115.711104
Blowing Out12022070.172.927156

As suspected, the easy answer appears to be the correct one. When the wind blows out, the Cubs offense is great. When it blows in, the offense just blows. Not shocking stuff.

Here is the correlation of wind to temperature:

Temperature and windPAsRunsR/PAOPSwRC+
74 and below wind in676670.100.66190
74 and below wind out361620.172.923153
75 and above wind in237380.160.853144
75 and above wind out7811420.182.963167

So it is interesting to note that the offense is still fairly good for the Cubs at home if the wind is blowing in and the temps are above 75 degrees. But when the wind is blowing in and the temps are low, the offense crumbles. Lets take one more look at the wind blowing in and wind speed to see if that makes a big difference.

Wind SpeedPAsRunsR/PAOPSwRC+
1-5 mph in187160.086.69698
6-10 mph in253360.142.7651118
11-15 mph in140100.071.48640
20 or higher mph in130100.077.60683

So when the wind is howling in, the Cubs can’t score. Another less than shocking development.

Now the flip side. What happens to the pitching in Wrigley based on the weather

Temperature and windIPERAFIPHR/9
74 and below wind in183.23.193.290.88
74 and below wind out82.1625.531.53
75 and above wind in53.23.194.011.01
75 and above wind out175.15.855.632.10

Another less than shocking development.

So what does this mean for the Cubs in the playoffs? With their inability to manufacture runs, and reliance on slugging, it might actually better for them to go to a warmer weather spot.

However, the pitching will certainly give up more runs, especially Imanaga, Boyd and Gausman, who have had problems with giving up home runs.

Couple the potential for poor pitching results with other disadvantages of being a road team, and I still think it is a net negative for the Cubs. But at least we should see some offense.


Discover more from Cubs in 7

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a comment